Five-Path Comparison
One set of heirs seen five ways: three classical scholarly opinions (tarjih · Zayd · Hanbali) beside the state law (KHI). Rows that differ are highlighted — so you can see exactly where Indonesian law departs from the scholars’ paths.
One set of heirs, five viewpoints. Three classical opinions beside the state law (KHI); rows whose amounts differ are highlighted. The KHI column computes in full: marital property, substitute heirs, and wasiat wajibah.
KHI: the surviving spouse takes 1/2 of this first (Pasal 96), then the rest is divided.
Husband and wife cannot both be set.
Add a child who died first; their share passes to their children (grandchildren), split 2:1.
| Heir | Contemporary tarjih (Ibn Uthaymin · al-Fawzan) | Zayd's system / Shafi'i (Ar-Rahabi) | Official Hanbali madhhab | KHI (Indonesia) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wife(s) | Rp 30.000.000 | Rp 30.000.000 | Rp 30.000.000 | Rp 30.000.000 |
| Son(s) | Rp 168.000.000 | Rp 168.000.000 | Rp 168.000.000 | Rp 168.000.000 |
| Daughter(s) | Rp 42.000.000 | Rp 42.000.000 | Rp 42.000.000 | Rp 42.000.000 |
Every path gives the same amounts for this set.
The KHI column uses the KHI options above. For the rules themselves, see the KHI path. A study aid, not a fatwa.
Open the KHI path