Inheritance Calculation According to Shaykh Ash-Shinqiti
The tafsir path — each rule’s evidence, the wisdom, and an honest dispute map.
The science of faraidh from a direction the three earlier Warismatika bundles haven’t taken: tafsir — how Shaykh Muhammad al-Amin ash-Shinqiti (d. 1393 AH) derives inheritance law directly from An-Nisa 11, 12, and 176 in Adhwa’ al-Bayan, using the method of “the Qur’an explained by the Qur’an.” Sixteen files: three verses dissected, a system assembled with a traceable line of evidence, six case studies each carrying an evidence column, a chapter on wisdom, and an honest map of where ijtihad territory begins.
Summary (TL;DR)
All the fixed-share (furudh) numbers turn out to trace back to three verses; the sunnah fills in substitute positions and establishes ‘ashabah; the rest (‘awl, radd, the grandfather-alongside-siblings) is the Companions’ ijtihad — and knowing where these three layers end is the core of ash-Shinqiti’s path. The distinctive feature of his tafsir that this bundle highlights: the wisdom behind 2:1 is answered with the verse on qawwamah (An-Nisa 34), the puzzle of “two daughters = 2/3” is untangled with usul tools (mafhum ash-shart vs mafhum az-zarf) plus a bridge to verse 176, and the two kalalah verses are reconciled as two regimes of siblings (maternal half-siblings vs full/paternal half-siblings). This bundle does not calculate disputed cases — it maps them and points to the sibling bundles; in exchange it gives what no other path has: the root evidence for every rule and answers to modern objections.
Key points:
- Three layers of the system: verse (all furudh numbers) → sunnah (grandmother, grandchildren, ‘ashabah, blocking) → ijtihad (‘awl, radd, the grandfather) — the lineage table is in chapter 05, the quick version in chapter 13.
- This bundle’s signature habit: an evidence column in the worksheet — every line of calculation points to its verse or hadith (chapter 06).
- Six case studies are designed within nash territory (by verse: 11, 12, 176, and mixed) — case F shows just how thin the line is between a safe question and a disputed case.
- The wisdom chapter (chapter 11): three common objections answered the tafsir way — verse against verse.
- Start learning to calculate with the Ibn Uthaymin bundle; this bundle roots what you learn there, it does not replace it (chapter 12).
5W+1H
| Question | Short answer | Chapter |
|---|---|---|
| What | Faraidh derived from tafsir of its verses (Adhwa’ al-Bayan) | 01–02 |
| Why | Knowing where each rule comes from: memorization becomes understanding; ready to answer objections | 01, 11 |
| Who | Ash-Shinqiti (Mauritania→Madinah, d. 1393 AH); his completing student Atiyyah Salim | 01 |
| When/Where | After the 5 prior rights are settled; the verses’ context & the Indonesian context (disputes + KHI) | 06, 07, 12 |
| How | Dissect 3 verses → assemble the system → calculate with an evidence column → map the disputes | 03–07, practiced in 08–10 |
Concept map: how the calculation works
flowchart TB
classDef start fill:#374151,stroke:#9ca3af,color:#f3f4f6
classDef core fill:#134e4a,stroke:#14b8a6,color:#ccfbf1
classDef how fill:#713f12,stroke:#ca8a04,color:#fef9c3
classDef out fill:#1e3a8a,stroke:#3b82f6,color:#dbeafe
H["The estate left behind"]:::start --> R["Subtract: burial costs, debts, bequests (max 1/3)"]:::start
R --> T["TIRKAH — the estate to divide"]:::core
T --> F["Ashabul furudh — fixed shares<br/>1/2 · 1/4 · 1/8 · 2/3 · 1/3 · 1/6"]:::core
T --> A["'Ashabah — take the residue<br/>(nearest male relatives)"]:::core
F --> HJ["Filter by HAJB<br/>the nearer blocks the farther"]:::how
A --> HJ
HJ --> K["Correct if it doesn't fit<br/>'awl · radd · tashih"]:::how
K --> D["Final share for each heir"]:::out
This flow is shared across the classical paths; ash-Shinqiti’s hallmark: every rule is traced to its source (verse → sunnah → ijtihad), not merely memorised.
Reading order
- 01 — The big picture and ash-Shinqiti
- 02 — Three inheritance verses
- 03 — Mining verse 11 · 04 — Verses 12 & 176: kalalah
- 05 — From verses to system · 06 — Calculation engine
- 07 — Dispute map
- 08 · 09 · 10 — case studies by verse
- 11 — Wisdom & answering objections
- 12 — Comparing the four paths · 13 — Quick evidence map · 14 — Glossary · 15 — References
Prerequisites & notes
- Prerequisite: best enjoyed once you can already calculate (the Ibn Uthaymin bundle); still readable standalone for anyone chasing the evidence.
- Attribution honesty: only discussion verified as being in Adhwa’ al-Bayan is attributed to ash-Shinqiti; disputed cases are not calculated here, they are mapped to the sibling bundles.
- The Indonesian version is in the sibling bundle:
perhitungan-waris-asy-syinqithi-id/.
Chapters
- 01 — Big Picture: Ash-Shinqiti and the "Faraidh from Its Verses" Path →
- 02 — Three Inheritance Verses: The Map Before Mining →
- 03 — Mining Verse 11: Ash-Shinqiti's Distinctive Discussions →
- 04 — Verses 12 and 176: Two Kalalah Verses That Explain Each Other →
- 05 — From Verses to System: Assembling the Faraidh Machine →
- 06 — The Calculation Machine: The 7-Step Procedure →
- 07 — Dispute Map: The Area the Verses Do Not Decide →
- 08 — Verse 11 Case Studies (2 cases) →
- 09 — Verse 12 Case Studies (2 cases) →
- 10 — Verse 176 and Mixed Case Studies (2 cases) →
- 11 — The Wisdom of the Distribution and Answering Objections →
- 12 — Comparing the Four Paths, Evaluation, and Recommendation →
- 13 — Quick Evidence Map: Rule → Source →
- 14 — Glossary →
- 15 — References →